Bottoms Up, Butterbeer

HPBannerFinalTall Butterbeer
Madam
Rosmerta would agree that no wizard party is complete without a pint of
freshly-brewed Butterbeer. With our house elf now missing, it took us
quite a few iterations before we discovered the perfect potion for this
usually overly-sweet concoction. A hint of ginger and the sweetness of
butterscotch combine to create a delightful and refreshing non-alcoholic drink,
capable of making even Severus Snape smile.

Butterscotch300 Butterbeer Recipe

12 oz. (one bottle) ginger beer
36 oz. (three bottles) cream soda
3 T butterscotch ice cream topping

Thoroughly
chill unopened ginger beer and cream soda in refrigerator until
icy-cold.  Refrigerate empty, glass pitcher as well.  Once beverages
are chilled, in a small mixing bowl or tall glass, stir 1-2 oz. of
cream soda into butterscotch topping till thoroughly combined.  Pour
all remaining soda into chilled pitcher. Quickly add butterscotch
mixture to pitcher.  Stir till just combined;  do not over-stir.  Pour
over ice and serve immediately.  Serves 6.

For a frothy sparkle, dip the rim of each glass in corn syrup,
pulling drips of syrup downward with a toothpick.  Then dip
each glass rim in a mixture of colored sugar.  Before dipping, spread
the corn syrup & sugar mixture each onto a separate, flat-bottomed
plate.

SugarRim

For
an old-world, textured effect, mix fine, yellow sugar with coarser,
gold sugar.  Colored sugars are available at many grocery stores and
craft chains.  The sugars shown here are both from Michael's.

Isaac
& I went to a midnight showing of The Half-Blood Prince with friends last
night.  It was amazing — definitely my favorite HP movie so far — BY
FAR.  We were surrounded by eight packed theatres of screaming,
costumed teenagers.  It was a sight.

• Cockroach Clusters recipe here.

45 Comments

  1. Sneaked away to see the movie this afternoon. Agree that it’s the best so far. A very nice redemption from #5. Thanks for another fun recipe. I’ll be serving it soon in Kansas City!

  2. Heather, I am loving how you are coming up with such fun HP goodies! Are you planning a party? I took my 15 year old daughter this morning to the 9am showing and it was PACKED! no costumed teens… that would’ve been fun. we LOVED it too!!!
    🙂 Missy

  3. I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE these recipes! We are planning a HP party as a family and I plan to use your recipe’s. I’ll link to your site when I share our party on my blog!! (It will be a while though, I’m slow)

  4. Heather, you are just too cute with your cockroaches and broomsticks! I’m a big fan of yours, this blog is one of my homepages and I always enjoy checking in to see what is new in your world. All the best to you!

  5. This sounds delicious. =)
    I saw HP last night. It was definitely the best film by far. I still can’t help but love the books more. But I enjoyed the movie. The acting was stronger, the cinematography better, and the overall pace of the film was less choppy, and more detailed.

  6. How fun! Our middle daughter is at ROTC camp until next week so we are all waiting for her return so we can see the movie together. I’ll surprise her with your recipes–thanks.

  7. These Harry Potter ideas are so much fun! I think I’m going to have to make them both and have a viewing of a couple of the past movies before seing the newest!
    I just made a Happy Stacker and it turned out so cute. I liked it so much I’m making another! I just put a picture of it on my (rather ordinary) blog!
    Cheers from STL!

  8. I’d love to get my hands on a tall glass of that Butterbeer!
    We saw the movie yesterday and I agree- this was the best of them all.

  9. What a wonderful treat for after the movie! The rimmed glasses are very cool. I’m surprised – I just noticed the the little 2-plex in my town actually has HP on opening week! (It usually takes a few weeks for movies to get here…) 🙂

  10. Amazing, we went to see the film as well.
    I thought it was the best one yet.
    And very funny.
    Thanks for the recipe, my family will love it.

  11. I can’t agree with you on the movie, *spolier* hated the omission of the battle at Hogwarts and the heart wrenching funeral. However, I can agree that you are the bomb diggity for sharing this delicious recipe, can’t wait try it out.

  12. Where did you get the little straw brooms? Did you make them or buy them?
    I’m a grad student and I LOVE with Halloween, and I’ve made it my business to throw a party for our department every year. I will definitely be making these drinks and the cockroach clusters this year! Do you have any more Halloween-ish ideas? I would love to see what else you have up your sleeves…

  13. Your recipe sounds perfect and I love the presentation. Now I just need a recipe for butter pies from “A Tale of Time City”.

  14. You’re in luck, Emily. I just posted a tutorial for the brooms. If there was a link to your site, I’d stop by to let you know. Hopefully you’ll be back by soon to see the broom how-tos.

  15. This looks delicious! Do you think it would work as well with a butterscotch essence instead? I’ve never seen Butterscotch flavoured icecream topping here in NZ, but occasionally I’ll see a small bottle of Butterscotch essence. I suspect the syrupy-ness of the topping adds to charm of the drink though 🙁

  16. sweet!! some friends and i were lucky enough to get to see the screening a couple of days before it opened and had mentioned afterwards how butter beer always looks so amazing!! and here you are…supplying a recipe. YOU are amazing! 🙂

  17. I’ve favorited all the Harry Potter Hoopla posts to use with my girls. They are going to die!
    I’m writing a post about all the wonderful Harry Potter creations you have and was wondering if I may use one of the photos (preferably the butterbeer with the broomsticks) to make it more enticing for readers to come visit. I’d make the picture a link itself as well. I plan on posting it on Tuesday. Please let me know either way at chocolateonmycranium [at] live [dot] com.
    Thanks!

  18. Heather…I love you! Let me tell you these Harry Potter Hoopla’s posts are the coolest! During the movie when then were all drinking their butter beer I was thinking, “that looks so good, I wish it were a real drink!” And whala! You have made it. Brilliant!

  19. I totally am in love with this idea! I’ll have to save it for next year, I alternate Halloween and Christmas parties, and this year is Christmas. Is it ok to post about it on my site?

  20. I like this nice post regarding ginger and the sweetness of caramel to create a pleasant and refreshing soft drink, will be able to even smile at Severus Snape.

  21. Hello!
    I wanted to let you know that this post has been included in a collection on my blog. I am an Event Designer, and I put together a weekly post as part of my series, “The Sparkle Queen Events”. Each week a concept that I’ve designed is featured in detail on my site. The elements that make up these events are a combination ideas and images I’ve found all over the internet. I piece them together and turn them into a beautiful, coherent event concept.
    This is a link to the direct post:
    http://sparklysharpandfabulous.blogspot.com/2012/10/halloween-party-for-adults-only.html
    Links to your idea have been included in the post for my viewers to find easier! This event will be shared and showcased not only on my blog, but also on my social media accounts such as Pinterest, Facebook, Twitter, etc.. , I’d love to connect pages via social media, so I can showcase your item and share it better with my followers.
    I hope you get a chance to see the post!
    <3 The Sparkle Queen from sparklysharpandfabulous.blogspot.com

  22. Would also be neat, instead of using sugar on the rim, perhaps use crushed butterscotch candies? Just a thought 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *